

Romancing the history
Beautiful and perceptive
A very beautiful, perceptive book

SOLDIER BOY; GOOD BOOK WITH A BAD ENDING
Soldier Boy was exciting and wonderfully written.
A good book

Interesting, but too much cheerleading.Urwin's task is not too difficult. GA Custer's Civil War career was pretty spectacular. Promoted from a staff position to the command of a cavarly brigade on the eve of the battle of Gettysburg, Custer would prove to be an outstanding combat commander in virtually every engagement his unit fought in. Eventually, his profiency as a brigade commander would earn him the command of the 3rd Cavarly Division and a promotion to brevet major general at the age of 25.
Custer's critics like to point out that Custer's units suffered high casualties and that his successes were more a result of dumb luck than any tactical ability, Urwin ably destroys these misconceptions. It is true that Custer's men suffered heavy casualties, but that was unfortunately the cost of victory on Civil War battlefields. Also Custer never got the reputation for being careless with the lives of his men. His willingness to share in any danger that his men faced and the victories and prestige his units garnered under his command created admiration rather than resentment among his men. To prove this Urwin provides quotes from admiring subordinates and constantly refers to the 3rd Division as the "Red Tie boys" to remind the reader that many men in that unit wore red ties around their necks in tribute to the one worn by their long-haired commander. Urwin also utterly destroys the idea that Custer was a tactical buffoon who lucked into victories with flashy cavalry charges. Urwin shows that Custer used a mixture of dismounted and mounted tactics to overcome his opponents. He also shows that Custer had a good eye for terrain and keen sense when to launch a charge, which he used to great advantage during the later campaigns of the Civil War.
Urwin does make a very convincing case that GA Custer was an outstanding combat commander. His use of primary sources to build his case is very thorough. However, Urwin undoes alot of his work by constant cheerleading. Urwin's Custer is too perfect. Custer did make mistakes, but Urwin either dismisses them or just glances over them. The entire book is written in this annoying "rah-rah" cheerleader style. Urwin's adoration of Custer is just too much and brings down the entire academic tone of the book. In his forward, Urwin makes a statement about how as a liberal democrat he does not worship military types, but then the rest of the text makes that statement absurb because it borders on almost idol worship.
"Custer Victorious'" research is impressive and because of that it almost overcomes its almost hagiographic tone to build a pretty solid case that Custer was an exceptional combat leader. However, its constant cheerleading will make some very skeptical of its assertions.
EXCELLENT
Thrilling Stories of an American HeroCuster's value in preserving the Union during the Civil War was so profound, General Phil Sheridan presented the table upon which the surrender was signed to Custer's wife and said "...there is scarcely an individual in our service who has contributed more to bring about this desirable result than your gallant husband."
This book relates many accounts of how Custer, arriving upon a battle, could instantly size up the situation and seize the initiative. He inspired his men in battle and when he ordered them to charge he would lead them personally, miraculously escaping the hundreds of bullets fired at him by an enemy who could easily recognize him by his long blonde hair and flamboyant dress. One of his cavalry troopers said, "Under him a man is ashamed to be cowardly. Under HIM our men can achieve wonders."
Following is a quote from the book, about Custer in the battle of Five Forks: " 'We are going to take those works and we are not coming back until we get them!' The Red Ties lunged ahead...Old Curly and his staff in front as always...General Custer's Bugler, Color Bearer, and Orderly...All went down...Miraculously, Custer was untouched by that scything fusillade. Swinging down from his saddle like a stunt rider, he grabbed his fallen guidon without dismounting, swirled it over his head, jammed his spurs into his horse, streaked right up to the enemy, and leaped his charger over the earthworks."
Custer's actions in the Civil War are now allowed to speak for themselves in Urwin's outstanding book. If you are interested in the Civil War and admire personal courage, you will enjoy "Custer Victorious."


Disappointed
outstanding primary source material
Class of 1861Incidentally, the picture of the front cover is believed to be the earliest photograph of the US Corps of Cadets at West Point. Although undated, it was probably taken sometime between 1860 and 1862.


Libbie Custer, LiteFor somebody who is completely unfamiliar with Elizabeth Custer and doesn't want to take the time to read Boots and Saddles or any of her other writings, A Life Within A Life is a fine place to start. For others, Leckie's 1993 biography (which Kines actually points to as the impetus for her book) will be a far more interesting read.
Interesting view on Custers life
An important view of a woman's life in the old West.The author (Pat Kines) brings personal family experience of the old West to enhance her book. Her Grandmother had direct encounters with hostile natives, and Pat and her family have always lived in the West.
Libbie was born in Monroe, Michigan. She kept a diary from which we learn a great deal about her and the life she lived. Libbie was from a wealthy family, was well educated, and had an intellectual sense of humor.
The book brings Libbie to life with a variety of anecdotes, words from Libbie's own hand, and relevant (and interesting) historical facts of the period. Of particular historical interest is the chapter titled, "After the Civil War". That chapter shows how Libbie, from the North, viewed the people from the South as they tried to regain some normalcy after losing the war.
The book describes Libbie's down-to-earth, every-day living conditions. The descriptions are excellent and include her life in Army tents, how she traveled with her personal and military entourage, what it was like for her to stay at various forts, and how she and the other occupants of the forts (men and women) entertained themselves. Life was very hard at times, but Libbie was determined to remain a lady no matter how difficult the living conditions became.
Entertainment at the forts was very important and included dancing, singing, riding outside of the fort (even in inclement weather), and picnics. Sometimes the military band from the fort played at the picnics!
Libbie outlived her husband by fifty years, during which time she made a successful life by herself. She was able to travel a great deal and had many friends around the world.
I think that "A life within a life" is an important as well as interesting book. It shows Libbie to be a resourceful woman dedicated to her husband and at the same time she was independent and caring of those less fortunate. The book is a perfect candidate for Oprah's Book Club.


Not the parts reference it claims to be
Excelent!
A "must have" book for the M1 Garand collector

A surprising Thesis about LITTLE BIG HORN "Massacre" !
Keep the last bullet for yourself

Good post-Civil War read.
wow, another hit

unlike any other biagraphy i'v ever read.
Freaks of the Morning Star: reviewing A Wounded thing. . .Also fiercely devoted are all those people who have been hopelessly entraced by the Custer myth, who are just short of, well, nuts. While in Monroe, MI, you can actually go on a tour of the Custer's honeymoon (there wasn't one, so you get to walk on the same sidewalk), and recreate their wedding ceremony. On the anniversary of Custer's death on June 25, you can go to the barber and get a "Custer Cut"--"Custer Cut, Custer Prices". All of this craziness is treated with great humour by Poolman and is almost more interesting than the story of Libbie and her long widowhood.
Sometimes Poolman's modern dialogue is hard to follow, and some parts were a little gratuitous, but all in all, you cannot read this book and not smile, even just a little.


doesn't follow the evidence
Mystery no more?
For the non-expert this can be a little overwhelming
Heyen has his own vocabulary throughout the book and manages to make historical figures all fit into his special universe, like everybody turned up on his writingdesk and got special instructions from Heyen on how they should react to special things. The remarkable is that Heyen stays very true and close to historical facts and is accurate, as far as I can trace him, throughout the book.
Of course Heyen, through the two protagonists Custer and Crazy Horse, makes it almost a fight between industrialization and nature, civilisation against free spirit. Heyen knows well that in todays society Custer is the winner, but still the other part of us still want to be free, perhaps only in different ways than C.H.